0

Government backs down over homebirthing legislation

Posted by Melissa Maimann on Sep 4, 2009 in Home birth, Midwifery

For further information, contact Melissa Maimann at Essential Birth Consulting.

Link

The Federal Government has backed down on controversial legislation that would have seen homebirthing effectively made illegal.

… Under the draft laws, midwives must be insured to join the register but private insurers no longer provide cover for homebirthing and the government has also refused to subsidise professional indemnity for homebirth claims.

As a result, up to 200 independent midwives faced deregistration from July 2010 and, if they continued working, risked fines of up to $30,000.

… following a meeting of state and territory health ministers … Nicola Roxon announced a two year exemption from holding indemnity insurance for privately practising midwives who can’t obtain cover for attending a homebirth.

To take advantage of the exemption, homebirthing midwives will be required to tell women they are not insured, report each homebirth they attend and participate in a quality and safety framework which will be developed after consultations led by the Victorian government.

… “I was concerned that as an unintended consequence of the national registration and accreditation process that homebirthing may be driven underground, that that would not be a good outcome.

“This arrangement agreed to today ensures that homebirthing midwives can lawfully continue to provide their services in jurisdictions where that’s allowed.”

That’s concerning …. where is it allowed?

Ms Roxon said the government would ask the National Nursing and Midwifery Board to give advice on protocols for homebirthing outside the public health system.

I don’t believe anyone on the new Board is a private midwife who attends home births. And I question the wisdom of inviting nurses to have input into the midwifery profession. Are optometrists asked to give comment on psychology practice?

“We have a process to be able to work further on protocols that would either bring more homebirthing services into our public system or potentially open the way in the future for an insurance product to be extended to cover them,” she said.

I have a better idea. Keep hospital birth in the hospitals, and keep home birth at home. If private home birth is allowed to continue legally, then we ought to promote private home birth services, not the public hospital services that cater best to risk-associated pregnancies.

“This two year exemption allows plenty more time for those protocols to be established and worked on.”

… “We’ve undertaken a maternity services review process which did not recommend that public funding be provided for homebirthing and we stick by that advice,” she said.

Home birth has never been funded by the Govt.

Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448

Tags: , , , ,

 
3

Home birth with a private midwife will be exempt from insurance requirements

Posted by Melissa Maimann on Sep 4, 2009 in Birth, Home birth, Midwifery

For further information, contact Melissa Maimann at Essential Birth Consulting.

Link

Pregnant women wanting to give birth at home have won a reprieve after Federal Government and the States cut a deal today to allow midwives to continue practising without insurance.

Health Minister Nicola Roxon announced privately practising midwives would have a two year exemption from obtaining medical indemnity cover.

… Under the deal announced today following the Health Ministers conference in Canberra, midwives will be able to keep practising homebirths provided they warn expectant mothers they do not have insurance, they follow quality and safety guidelines being developed and each homebirth is reported to health authorities.

The exemption will last until June 2012 …

Fantastic news!! The details are still hazy though – will home birth be funded in any way? Will midwives who attend births at home be able to access PBS and order tests for their clients? Midwives will need to have insurance to register. What is the situation for midwives who only attend births at home? It seems that they will need to purchase an insurance product that they cannot use!

Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

 
0

Deaths at Birth Illuminate Tanzania’s Health Challenges

Posted by Melissa Maimann on Sep 4, 2009 in Birth, Caesarean, Midwifery, Obstetrics

For further information, contact Melissa Maimann at Essential Birth Consulting.

Link

In Wayali Hospital in Bagamoyo, Imani Msisi – just over eight months pregnant – lies motionless on a narrow metal bed, pressing a thin sheet to her chest.

She was referred to the hospital several days ago because of unusually sharp pains in her abdomen. There is no nurse or doctor in Msisi’s village, only a health officer with some basic medical training. Fearing the worst, he sent Msisi in a taxi on the nearly hour drive to Wayali.

She was found to be having a false labor and was treated at the hospital, but is being kept there until she gives birth. If Msisi goes home and a complication does occur, she may not be able to make it back in time.

“In the villages … If [pregnant women] are hemorrhaging they are transferred here but sometimes they die before they leave …” …

According to the most recent maternal mortality data … 578 women died in 2004 per every 100,000 live births, and that rate has increased since 1999.

World Health Organization data paints an even bleaker picture, listing the Tanzania maternal mortality rate for 2005 at 950 deaths for every 100,000 live births. In comparison, the United States had 11 maternal deaths for every 100,000 live births in 2005.

… The leading cause of maternal death in Tanzania is excessive bleeding before or after birth … Infection and high blood pressure also cause many maternal fatalities …

… “In the rural areas [it is] an average of 5 to 10 kilometers for someone to walk to the nearest health facility …” …

… the ministry is planning to have a dispensary and health officer in each village, and is upgrading some dispensaries to health clinics, which can handle minor operations. The country is also working to train more health professionals to ease the dire nursing and doctor shortage in the country.

Assistant medical officers, with three years of medical training, have had to take up many of the responsibilities of doctors in Tanzania, and perform about 80 percent of cesarean sections.

… About 53 percent of deliveries in Tanzania are attended by unskilled people, while 47 are attended by skilled health care professionals …

“… [traditional healers] are a necessary evil,” … because there simply are not enough health workers and some people only trust healers. In response the government is trying to provide some training to traditional healers, teaching them to recognize danger signs and providing them with antiseptics.

… maternal deaths are “just a part of life” and she estimates the Morogoro hospital sees as many as 20 maternal deaths in a month.

… “You could have three or four birth on one day,” Massi said. “Sometimes if they are rushing they can’t sterilize the equipment between births so that is dangerous.”

… While assistant medical officers are an important resource, Im says she gets angry when she sees women suffering with botched cesarean sections, which should be a simple operation.

… Efforts to educate women about the importance of antenatal care have been successful …

Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448

Tags: , , , , , ,

 
0

Morphine ‘helped kill new mother Petah Kimm’

Posted by Melissa Maimann on Sep 4, 2009 in Caesarean

For further information, contact Melissa Maimann at Essential Birth Consulting.

Link

A WOMAN who was left unattended for two hours after giving birth in a Sydney hospital was found dead with a high level of morphine …

Petah Kimm died in June 2006, when her blood pressure suddenly dropped just hours after giving birth by caesarean section at Nepean Hospital …

… a medical emergency team was not called when Ms Kimm’s blood pressure dropped …

… nobody had checked on Ms Kimm until two hours later, when she was already dead.

A student midwife, who had checked on Ms Kimm, had failed to notify an experienced nurse when her blood pressure dropped, the investigation found.

Nurses were also concerned about the amount of blood Ms Kimm had lost during childbirth.

Anaesthetic nurse Denise Johnston and ’scrub scout’ Rebecca Roseby both gave evidence that they noticed a “significant” amount of blood … when they were transferring her from the operating theatre to the bed.

… She had raised her concerns with Dr Ralph Nader, who had told her it was not a concern …

… she died from soft-tissue haemorrhage after the caesarean birth, and that morphine toxicity might have been a significant contributing factor.

… doctors would give evidence that the amount of morphine injected “seemed to be sufficient … in the resulting of her death”.

… Ms Kimm’s blood pressure had dropped to a low level on four occasions.

Stay safe: birth at home wherever possible. You will have one-to-one care from a known midwife and eliminate the risks of having several care providers, each providing parts of your care. Birth is an holistic experience that demands the holistic care that a private midwife can provide. The above story demonstrates exactly what happens when multiple care providers are providing care to a woman they do not know. Add staff shortages, inexperienced staff, possible inadequate supervision of the student midwife (where was the supervising midwife? Why was the student midwife left to report to a nurse?) and lack of due concern to the mix, and you have a recipe for disaster.

Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448

Tags: , , , , ,

Copyright © 2010 Private Midwife: Homebirth & Hospital Birth All rights reserved. Theme by Laptop Geek.