Posted by Melissa Maimann on Mar 10, 2010 in
Birth,
Caesarean,
Home birth,
Midwifery,
Normal Birth,
Obstetrics Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Can I home birth if I have a high blood pressure?
It is best to discuss this with your midwife and s/he can guide you on this one.
Can you opt for a c-section in a public hospital?
Generally speaking, you cannot do this. Caesareans are only performed where there is a clear obstetric reason. Many women have support people with them for their labour and this helps them to feel more comfortable and in control of their experience.
Can you refuse midwife attendance during birth?
You can refuse to have a midwife with you if you choose, but this would leave you without professional care during the birth.
What care is available to women birthing in australia?
Within the private system, women may choose a midwife for a home or a hospital birth and they will generally experience an empowering and natural birth without complications. If there are complications in the pregnancy or birth, obstetric care is readily available. The other option in the private system is to choose an obstetrician. Intervention rates with obstetricians are high, with caesarean rates up to (and over) 50%, episiotomy rates around 25% and assisted delivery rates around 25%.
In the public system, midwifery care is the norm, but most women will not have the same midwife all the way through their pregnancy, birth and postnatal period. If there are complications in the pregnancy or birth, obstetric care is readily available.
Continuity of midwifery care
The most established method of continuity of midwifery care is private midwifery care or independent midwifery. In this model, women book with the midwife of their choice and this same midwife is there for the woman throughout pregnancy, birth and the postnatal period. Satisfaction rates with this mode of care are very high.
IVF and home birth?
Yes, it is possible to bith at home following IVF. Talk to your midwife.
Are midwives qualified to do cesareans?
No, midwives are qualified in normal pregnancy and birthing, and we do not perform surgery.
Natural labour in sydney?
The best way to achieve a truly natural labour is to book with a private midwife for a home birth or a hospital birth. Home is the safest place to birth for the majority of women, and home – where women feel safe, nurtured and supported – is the most conducive environment for a natural birth.
Are there any obstetricians in sydney under $5000?
The best way to research prices is to ask the obstetricians themselves. Don’t forget, the ob’s bill is not the only bill you will receive: there is also the paediatrician, anaesthetist, private hospital fees, health fund excess / co-payment, childbirth education and so on.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Birth choices, Caesarean, Complicated pregnancy or birth, continuity of care, Home birth, hospital birth, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Normal Birth, Obstetrics, Public and private hospitals
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Mar 9, 2010 in
Birth,
Midwifery,
Obstetrics Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
“Get Me Out: A History of Childbirth” by Randi Hutter Epstein, M.D., 2010, W.W. Norton & Co., $24.95/$31 Canada, 320 pages
You’ve known for days.
The urpy-ness before breakfast (when you can eat breakfast), the swollen bits, the tender bits, all good indications. Even the home-kit was positive but it wasn’t “official” until the doctor said it: you’re pregnant.
But after leaving your first prenatal exam – and after more tests than you’ve had in your lifetime – your mother (overjoyed) read through some information you received and said she never remembered half that stuff when you were born. Grandma (ecstatic) said she wasn’t even awake when your mom was delivered.
Have we come a long way, baby? Yes and no, as you’ll see when you read “Get Me Out” by Randi Hutter Epstein, M.D.
Let’s start in the year 1530. You’re about to become somebody’s mom. Because a sign on the door of your room says “no boys allowed,” you’re surrounded by girlfriends, female relatives and a midwife (if you could afford her). They would have herbs for you, food and drink. Someone might consult a book of pregnancy advice (available for thousands of years). You’d labor with people you knew.
But as an almost-mom in 1530, don’t expect anything for your pain. In 1591, a laboring mother (of twins!) was burned at the stake because she dared to ask for relief.
Fast forward three hundred years.
You’re at a lying-in hospital, so-called because post-delivery recovery takes weeks of bed rest. You might be allowed visitors, but no midwives; male doctors have convinced the general population that midwives are dangerous. Giving birth away from home and family, you’re told, is best for you and the baby.
But there at the hospital, mortality rates are sky-high. A woman might deliver on Monday, feel a little feverish on Wednesday and be dead by Friday. Wouldn’t simple hand-washing be a good idea?
Fast forward a century-and-three-quarters.
By now, doctors know how to repair fistulas (thanks to hundreds of slave women who were operated on without anesthesia), we know that what goes into mom crosses the placenta to baby, and we know how to make a baby in more ways than one.
Fast forward to you.
You’ve got lots of options; more, for sure, than ever before. And if you don’t like any of them, you can join the freebirthers and do it yourself because, hey, that method appears to have worked for millions of years.
Lively, slightly saucy and nowhere near a how-to advice book, “Get Me Out” is a great read that’s purely for the curious, whether a parent or not.
Author Epstein looks closely at the entire baby industry in this book, moving easily between the Middle Ages and modern times, in the laboratory and in the bedroom, from “aha!” moments to plenty of major oopses.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: birth, Birth choices, Home birth, hospital birth, midwife, Midwifery, Obstetrics
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Mar 2, 2010 in
Birth,
Midwifery,
Obstetrics Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Link
PARENTS of a baby delivered stillborn … claim medical staff repeatedly ignored warning signs their unborn baby was distressed.
… Documents … allege a midwife ignored and turned down the volume of an echocardiogram alarm that sounded for more than three hours …
The documents also claim Mrs Body was diagnosed and treated for deep vein thrombosis and thrombophilia (blood clotting) …
She alleges the hospital ought to have known her medical history and the risks associated and failed to recognise a natural birth “could not be performed safely”.
The documents show Mrs Body was admitted to hospital at 8am on February 26, 2007, and was monitored at half-hour intervals between 9.30am and 3pm.
Her waters were broken by a doctor about 4pm and at 4.30pm an epidural was administered.
It is alleged that at 5.10pm an echocardiogram alarm attached to Mrs Body began making loud noises, but the volume was turned down by a midwife … four other times when the alarm sounded … it was turned down by the same midwife.
Monitors alarm quite often. They do not tell the midwife that the baby is distressed, they prompt the midwife to check the trace and ensure that it is ok. If the midwife determines that the baby is fine, the monitor sound is turned down.
The echocardiogram alarm continued to sound until 8.20pm but medical staff did not respond to it.
It wasn’t until 9.30pm, when Mr Body requested for Mrs Body to have an internal exam that one was performed, court documents claim.
It’s normal practice to leave 4 hours between examinations.
By 10.40pm, Mrs Body was told the baby’s heart rate was “low” and “we need to get her out now”.
This is not an uncommon scenario when a woman has had intervention in her birth. In this case, the woman had her waters broken, had an epidural and presumably also had a syntocinon infusion. All of these can stress babies. I also wonder what position she had been labouring in. It’s common for women with epidurals to labour on their backs and this does not help the baby to navigate the pelvis and be born, and it promotes fetal distress.
Paige Hannah Body was delivered by vacuum extraction about 11pm. She was not breathing and could not be revived … The State Government is yet to file a defence.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: childbirth education, Complicated pregnancy or birth, CTG, Epidural, fetal monitoring, hospital birth, intervention, midwife, Midwifery, Obstetrics, Public and private hospitals
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Mar 1, 2010 in
Home birth,
Midwifery Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Link
THE number of women choosing to give birth at home in Wales has reached a plateau …
Despite a rise in the birth rate, the percentage of home births has remained static at 3.7%.
But Wales still has the highest rate of home births in the UK.
The National Childbirth Trust (NCT) has said it was “very disappointed” about the lack of progress in Wales in raising the home birth rate.
Former Health Minister Jane Hutt said in 2003 that she wanted to see a 10% increase in the number of babies born at home over the course of a decade. And the Heads of Midwifery Advisory Group for Wales set a 10% home birth target for Wales to be achieved two years’ ago.
… “We need to see action … to deliver on policy commitments for choice. It is vital there are enough midwives and that they are supported.”
… almost 90% of women in the UK live in areas that “realistically do not offer the choice of a home birth with a midwife”.
… “We advocate home births because, with hospital births, the worry is that there is more risk of intervention.”
… women are twice as likely to need physical intervention when giving birth in hospital than at home. Women choosing home births are also less likely to rely on pain-relieving drugs … home births vary across Wales, from 9.5% in Bridgend to just 1.3% in Merthyr Tydfil.
“A target of 10% is quite a reasonable target. You would have to ask the Welsh Assembly Government why there is such a difference between areas. Sometimes it is down to midwife staffing levels but I would hope that is being looked at …
… “Home births provide women with an environment where they can feel more comfortable and as relaxed as possible …
I live for the day when Australia has a 10% home birth target!! We’re currently at about 0.3%.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Birth choices, continuity of care, Home birth, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Feb 28, 2010 in
Birth,
Home birth,
Midwifery,
Normal Birth,
Obstetrics,
VBAC Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Why are are home births with a mid wife preferred over a hospital delivery?
There are many benefits to birthing at home and having a midwife provide your care. The following pages will explain more about the benefits of birthing at home:
http://www.essentialbirthconsulting.com.au/home-birth.html
http://www.essentialbirthconsulting.com.au/home-birth/home-birth-benefits.html
I had a bad first birthing experience and I’m now waiting for my second baby.
It’s important to debrief your birth experience to help you to gain clarity around what happened and to explore strategies for helping the same situation to not happen again. Birth debriefing can also help you to choose a care provider who can support what it is you need for your second birth.
What are the benefits of having my baby with a midwife?
There are many benefits:
- Have the same care provider all the way through your pregnancy, birth and postnatal period
- Lower rates of intevention such as forceps, vacuum, episiotomy, induction, epidural
- More likely to breastfeed successfully
- Have continuous support from your midwife throughout labour
- Babies generally experience gentler births
What proportion of women birth at home with midwife?
Australia-wide, around 0.3%. In NSW, it’s around 0.2%. The low rate of homebirth is related to several factors:
- Homebirth is not actively supported by our health system, and hence it is not offered as an option to women when they see their GPs when they become pregnant.
- There is a perception that home birth is something only “hippies” or “alternative” people do. This could not be further from the truth!
- The cost of homebirth is prohibitive for some families as it is totally privately funded.
- In some areas, there are no midwives available.
Is it possible to contract a private midwife for postnatal care only?
Yes! Essential Birth Consulting provides postnatal care independent of birthing services.
Are there any VBAC friendly doctors at north shore private?
VBAC rates at North Shore Private are around 5% or lower and this is reflective of the obstetricians who practice there. Conversely, private midwives have VBAC rates as high as 90%. Obstetricians are surgicial specialists; midwives are specialists in normal, natural birth. If you’re after a normal birth (VBAC), you’re best to choose a care provider who specialises in this.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Birth choices, continuity of care, Home birth, hospital birth, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Normal Birth, Obstetrics, Public and private hospitals, VBAC
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Feb 27, 2010 in
Birth,
Midwifery,
Obstetrics Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Link
The Canberra Hospital’s obstetric training program could be at risk unless more doctors with surgical experience are found.
… workplace problems are preventing Canberra-based obstetricians from doing more public work.
As many as 16 registrars … can be attached to the Canberra Hospital Obstetric and Gynaecology Department at one time.
But RANZCOG spokesman Andrew Foote says five consultant obstetricians have left in just over a year.
“In order to do surgery, you need senior doctors who are seeing the cases and putting the cases on operating lists,” he said.
“That has fallen to a quite significant level.”
… the Canberra Hospital had “the potential to be a leader in the RANZCOG program throughout Australia and New Zealand.”
But in its recommendations it listed “dysfunctional relationships within the Obstetric and Gynaecology Department …
… conflict between senior staff … was having an impact on trainees.
… obstetricians would work at the hospital if the conditions were better.
… many of the doctors and registrars who have left the hospital … complained of a toxic workplace and uncooperative relationships with some midwives.
… they were concerned some midwives raised the alarm too late in emergency situations with potentially disastrous consequences.
“One of the cultural concerns I have is that there’s this ‘I’ve failed if I have to call in a doctor’, both at the patient level and at the midwife level,” …
… “This concept has been built up and perhaps sold to the public that it is possible to have a pregnancy unencumbered by any medical staff,” he said.
Gill Hall from the ACT College of Midwives says most doctors and midwives work well together.
“There’s a lot of people in both professions who are working very hard to change the culture and to make practice much more collaborative,” she said.
Health Minister Katy Gallagher says the Federal Government’s changes to Medicare which will reduce rebates to private obstetricians could be partly behind doctors raising the allegations.
“I think the building of a new Women’s and Children’s Hospital is causing turbulence and I think the sale of Calvary is causing turbulence,” she said …
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Complicated pregnancy or birth, hospital birth, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Obstetrics, Public and private hospitals
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Feb 25, 2010 in
Uncategorized Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
What does an obstetrician cost in Sydney?
Fees vary greatly. As well as considering obstetrician’s fees, also consider costs such as private health insurance co-payment or excess, extra fees and charges associated with private hospital stays, paediatrician and anaesthetist fees and additional costs for ultrasounds and tests. All up, you’re looking at somewhere between $2,000 and $10,000.
Private midwifery care, on the other hand, costs somewhere between $3,000 and $6,000.
Are there any antenatal / prenatal birthing classes in the Westmead area?
Yes, this service provides antenatal classes in the Westmead area.
What is the ceasearan rate in Australia in 2009?
This won’t be known until around 2011. In 2007 it was around the 30% mark and caesarean rates have increased most years. The current caesarean rate is around 30% – 35%.
induction vs cesarean and diabetes
What about another option? What about a natural birth? Provided that there are no complications as a result of the diabetes, this might be a great option to discuss with your care provider. You might also wish to seek a second opinion with a private midwife.
Intervention in midwifery?
Midwives are experts in natural birth, and therefore tend not to intervene in births. If intervention was felt to be necessary, an obstetrician would be consulted.
natural birth in a hospital australia?
Natural birth is far more likely in a homebirth (homebirth has an average transfer rate of 25% and the births that occur at home are 100% natural). In some hospitals in Australia, natural births are around 5%. Private midwifery care dramatically increases the chance of a natural birth in any setting.
Prenatal classes sydney
Yes, this service provides antenatal classes in Sydney.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: childbirth education, continuity of care, hospital birth, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Public and private hospitals
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Feb 25, 2010 in
Birth,
Home birth,
Midwifery Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Link
For Stephanie Foley … the home birth of her son Calvin was a “peaceful, great experience.”
And while Foley said she’s pleased with how her home birth went, and that she would do it again, the issue of the safety of out-of-hospital birth is up for debate.
Statistics show that while the desire for a less sterile, more intimate birth experience is growing, most mothers in the U.S. still have their babies in a hospital. It’s the prudent choice, safer if something goes wrong, experts say.
But it isn’t a simple call.
Family history, health of the mother and fetus, available and trusted midwives and personal preference all weigh in the decision.
On average, only 1 percent of all births in the U.S. are conducted out of hospitals annually …
Tori Kropp, a perinatal registered nurse at San Francisco’s California Pacific Medical Center, says it’s safer to give birth in a hospital.
… hospital births have gotten a bad rap due, in part, to the efforts of home-birth proponents, such as TV personality Ricki Lake.
Lake’s 2008 documentary “The Business of Being Born,” ignited a fire storm by implying many common medical practices may be doing new mothers more harm than good.
Kropp has participated in 5,000 births, including that of her 9-year-old son Alexander. By participating in so many deliveries Kropp said she has “seen all the things that can happen” during what is still a potentially dangerous event in a woman’s life.
Has she been at any homebirths? It’s totally ok to have an opinion in something that one has not seen, attended, experienced or directly been a part of. But if Kropp has never been to a home birth, only obstetricially-driven hospital births, who is she to say that home is not at least as safe as hospital for healthy, low-risk women who are attended by a midwife?
“Most of the time it’s wonderful, but sometimes it’s not,” Kropp said. “At the end of the day, it’s safer to give birth in a hospital.”
Through education and outreach Kropp strives to correct what she says is “misleading” information promoted by Lake’s film. ”
“The problem with many home births,” Kropp says, is that they are performed by midwives “without the support of either physicians or a hospital.”
And is that because the midwife has not consulted with the hospital or doctor, or because they were not willing to consult when it was requested?
To spread her message, Kropp is planning a 100-hospital tour across the country beginning in Michigan on Labor Day. Kropp plans to offer free pregnancy seminars at the hospitals …
Is she planning to get her message out to women who are planning to birth at home? If so, she can talk to the hospitals all she likes, she will not reach her intended audience.
Overall Kropp’s mission is a simple one – “helping women feel empowered about the choice they make, and not the choice society wants them to make.”
But … not if they choose to birth at home. It’s ok to choose an epidural or a caesarean though!
Regardless of birth location, 8 percent of births in 2006 were performed by midwives, according to the CDC.
Definitely room for improvement there. 80% would be a great target!
When Foley gave birth to her first and only child in December 2007 she and her husband lived in a one-bedroom, second-floor apartment in Lansing.
After about 6 hours of active labor, with the help of a direct-entry midwife, Foley gave birth to her son in an inflatable pool filled with water, which is described as a water birth.
… “Pregnancy and childbirth are normal, healthy events in a woman’s life and interventions, such as cesarean sections, should be used only when medically necessary, Winkler said. “Women choose to come to the birthing center for freedom of choice.”
But Winkler cautioned that women who have chronic diseases, such as kidney disease, high blood pressure or diabetes are “safest when (giving birth) at the hospital.”
Planned home births may have a low rate of complications …
Among 13,000 planned births studied, researchers found that the mortality rate was similarly low – less than one in 1,000 – among women who gave birth at home with a midwife, women who gave birth in a hospital with a midwife, and women who gave birth in a hospital with a physician.
… “Birth is safe. It is safe to give birth out-of-hospital when a woman is healthy and having a normal pregnancy,” Winkler said.
But Kropp says even if a woman is healthy, there is still the possibility of complications in childbirth.
“Our hospital system for childbirth is so far from perfect,” Kropp said. “But someone who is completely healthy could very easily have something very unexpected happen in childbirth. Childbirth is still the No. 1 cause of death for women (worldwide), so we can’t get too cavalier in saying ‘we don’t need medical help.’”
It’s the leading cause of death for women who are not suited to home birth, such as those in third world countries who experience malnutrition, undernutrition, anaemia, bleeding in pregnancy, high blood pressure and so on. For healthy, low-risk women, the benefits of home birth are enormous.
Foley said she considered safety when making her decision to give birth at home.
“I had had no reproductive issues … for me I felt that being at home would be as safe as at the hospital,” Foley said.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Birth choices, childbirth education, Complicated pregnancy or birth, continuity of care, Home birth, hospital birth, intervention, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Normal Birth, Public and private hospitals
Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
informed consent and childbirth
Every woman who is competent to consent, has the right to refuse any or all professional care. Informed consent must be obtained prior to any procedure being performed.
how to minimise labour intervention in a hospital?
The best way to minimise intervention in a hospital is to be as well informed as you can possible be about all things related to pregnancy, labour, birth, breastfeeding and babies. Read widely, attend independent childbirth education classes and consider employing a private midwife to be with you throughout your labour. She can help you to decide if the proposed interventions are necessary in your situation, she can support you emotionally, mentally and physically and she can aso help to ensure that your birth plan is respected without a fuss.
Do any independent midwives in Sydney offer prenatal care for women who are planning to freebirth?
Yes! This service enables women to access antenatal care from a midwife without the midwife attending the birth. Postnatal care is available if needed.
Do you think there are advantages to continuous monitoring for low-risk women
In a word, no. Intermittent auscultation is the method of choice. Continuous monitoring will increase the chance of a caesarean with no benefit to the mother or baby.
How much is a private midwife
Prices range from $3000 – $6000. Melissa Maimann offers for her clients to pay by the hour, making the service one of the cheapest.
What is a good caesarean rate?
The World Health Organisation recommends that no more than 15% births need to be caesareans. The WHO argues that when caesarean rates exceed 15%, the risks to the mother and baby increase on the whole. You’ll be hard-pressed to find a hospital with a caesarean rate of less than 15%, but birth centres and private midwives have caresarean rates of less than 10-15%.
What is the best hospital in sydney for delivering babies?
It all depends what sort of birth experience you’re after! If you’re wanting a natural birth, home birth will be the best option. If you want a natural birth in a hospital setting, the best options would be birth centre or private midwifery care for a planned hospital birth. If you’re wanting to have intervention in your birth, a hospital birth would be best. If you choose an obstetrician, you’re far more likely to have a caesarean, episiotomy, epidural, forceps or vacuum. Choosing your care provider is the single most important decision you will make in birthing.
Is there a birth centre at westmead hospital?
No, there isn’t. If you’re after a natural birth, the best choice would be a home birth.
C section or natural delivery midwife?
Midwves cannot perform caesareans. If a caesarean was needed, the midwife would call a doctor in to perform it. Most caesareans that are performed are unnecessary and increase the risks to the mother and baby. A natural birth is the safest way to birth, and midwives are qualified specialists in natural birth.
giving birth after birth trauma
Private midwifery care will be really important so that you can have the same midwife all the way through pregnancy, birth and postnatally. It’s also important to debrief your last experience and come to a place where you feel safe to birth again.
high risk midwife sydney
Midwives are not qualified to care for high risk pregnancies. We refer these women onto obstetricians. In most cases, one or two consultations is all that is needed with the obstetrician and the midwife continues the care of the woman.
how many births proceed naturally
What a great question! It all depends what care provider you choose and where you have your baby. You see, if you choose a private midwife and birth at home, you have about a 95% chance of having a vaginal birth. If you birth in a private hospital, you have about a 33% chace of having an unassisted vaginal birth. In some hospitals, the caesarean rate is more than the vaginal birth rate! Sad but true.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Babies, birth, Birth choices, birth debriefing, Birth trauma, Breastfeeding, Caesarean, childbirth education, Complicated pregnancy or birth, continuity of care, Epidural, exercise, fetal monitoring, freebirth, Home birth, hospital birth, intermittent auscultation, intervention, IVF, Maternity Services Review, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Normal Birth, Nutrition, Obstetrics, postnatal depression, Preconception care, Public and private hospitals, VBAC
Posted by Melissa Maimann on Feb 22, 2010 in
Home birth,
Midwifery Interested in home birth, hospital birth or private midwifery care? Questions or comments? Email Melissa Maimann or call 0400 418 448.
Link
IS giving birth at home a positive experience or and unnecessary risk?
ASK any expectant mother what she’s hoping for when she gives birth, and she’ll probably tell you the most important thing is to deliver a healthy, happy baby. But in recent years there’s been great debate about the best way to do this.
Is the ideal to have a child in the relaxed comfort of your own home, or does the medical expertise provided in hospital far outweigh the notion of giving birth in your own living room?
Although homebirth advocates argue the former, it appears the choice may soon be taken out of their hands.
Reports last year revealed that four babies in Sydney died in homebirths in the space of nine months, the NSW Government responded with a strong announcement: from July 2010, independent midwives will be unlikely to gain professional indemnity insurance – effectively making it illegal for them to assist at homebirths. The consequence? Homebirths are facing extinction.
Obstetrician Dr Pieter Mourik believes the ruling will stop women taking unnecessary risks.
“Women who choose to give birth at home expect everything to be normal, but they often don’t consider how far they are from expert help …” he says.
“Eighty per cent of women can have their babies in a paddock – but the problem is choosing these women. You just never know what will happen.”
However, Justine Caines, spokesperson for Homebirth Australia, says putting a blanket ban on homebirths will simply drive the practice underground.
… “Many mothers have had bad experiences in hospital and won’t repeat that.”
She continues: “Why does the government fund women who are choosing to have C-sections, but not women who are choosing to give birth at home?”LAST month a study of over 500,000 women in the Netherlands who gave birth at home … showed there was no significant difference between planned hospital births and planned homebirths in terms of babies dying during labour.
It’s important to note when making a comparison between Australia and the Netherlands, that the Netherlands only has low-risk home birth. If there are any complications in the pregnancy or labour, women see an obstetrician and birth in hospital. This is not the case in Australia at present, but it’s the system that the Govt is trying to set up.
… Dr Mourik says the study is misleading. “Firstly, we must remember Holland has very well-trained midwives who act almost like Australian GPs,” he says.
“It’s also a small country with maternity units often within 10 minutes of someone’s house. The conclusions of this study are based on the availability of well-trained midwives through a good transportation and referral system – and that simply isn’t the case in Australia.”
It’s not currently set up in Australia, but there’s no reason why it couldn’t be. A positive approach would be to set in place a system that supports women to birth at home, and a system that protescts the midwives who support women to birth at home. Home birth has always been and will always be. We can set it up so that it is safe, or we can hope it just goes away … it won’t.
However, despite warnings from obstetricians, women are still choosing to have their babies at home …
“Women should have the right to give birth wherever they feel safest – it’s up to them whether that’s in hospital or at home. But taking away our choice isn’t right. If there were more options within the hospital system, then perhaps more women would feel comfortable going to hospital.”
I disagree that women should make the decision: it should be made within the midwifery partnership. This debate is not about the right of women to bitrh at home: this right is protected by law. This debate is about the mdiwife’s responsibility to pracice safely.
The Health Minister is putting in place a system that will enable more women to access continuity of midwifery care with their chosen midwife in and out of the hospital system. Once this is in place, there will be more options within the hospital system, and hopefully fewer women who are traumatised by the hospital system.
So is there a way to keep everyone happy?
“Homebirth Australia would like the government to present a package for pregnant women that works a bit like the baby bonus,” … “Every woman would be given a sum of money to spend on her pregnancy treatment, then it’s up to her whether she sees a midwife at home, or an obstetrician in a hospital. It’s putting the choice back into women’s hands.”
What about the option to have a baby in hospital with a midwife, or the ability for an obstetrician to attend a woman at home?
However, Dr Mourik believes that when it comes to choice, the only factor to consider is the mother and baby’s health.
“Only a tiny minority of foolish women would risk their own lives and that of their precious babies for an ideal,” he says.
“How many doctors support homebirth? None I know – it’s too bloody risky.”
Many studies opint to the safety of home birth for low-risk women who are attended by a midwife. Women who birth at home are amongst the most health- and safety-conscious people I know. It is offensive to comment that women who birth at home are
risking their own lives and that of their babies, especially when the evidence is to the contrary.
Melissa Maimann, Essential Birth Consulting 0400 418 448
Tags: Birth choices, Complicated pregnancy or birth, continuity of care, freebirth, Home birth, hospital birth, Maternity Services Review, midwife, Midwifery, Midwifery services, Public and private hospitals, women's rights